Game Politics ([info]gamepolitics) wrote,
@ 2006-04-07 07:57:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Entry tags:a.g. crowe, diane feinstein, fepa, games-as-porn, legislation, letters, louisiana, roy burrell, sam brownback, u.s. senate

Gamer Voices Making Political Impact

Gamers are getting all political, and GP loves it!

We found this well written, extensively detailed letter to the editor in The Advocate (Baton Rouge). We don't know the writer, Jason Seneca, at least not by that name. But he's so smart, he must be a GP reader. Jason, if you're among us, please raise your hand.

Jason takes keyboard in hand to address twin "games as porn" bills under consideration by the Louisiana legislature. GP reported on the bills, introduced by Reps. A.G. Crowe (R) and Roy Burrell (D) a few weeks back. Jason writes, in part:

"I cannot speculate on Reps. Crowe's and Burrell's motivations for introducing such costly and frivolous legislation. Considering Louisiana's recent financial straits, I fail to see how taxpayers could support a motion that is unbalanced, has no basis in fact, will cost several hundred thousand dollars to support and is ultimately destined to fail. I urge our elected officials to employ the intelligence and foresight that their constituencies expect from them."

Impressive, Jason. And he's not the only one. Gamers have been taking advantage of the ESA's Video Game Voters Network to reach their elected officials. GP reader Sherwood42 wrote to Senator Diane Feinstein (D-CA) and got a response:

"Thank you for contacting me with your concerns about the Family Entertainment Protection Act. I appreciate hearing from you. In my lifetime, I have watched an increase in gratuitous violence and indecent sexually-explicit material in video games and the media as well as on television and the radio. I believe that some material is simply not appropriate for all audiences."

"As a grandmother, I often worry about what my own grandchildren are exposed to in video games... Federal regulations in this area and all others have developed through balancing two important principles:
protecting the well-being of minors while simultaneously following the constitutional protections afforded under the First Amendment. As legislation, such as (FEPA) is introduced... these will be my guiding principles. Please know that I will keep your particular concerns in mind should the Senate consider this bill.
"

Now, this was a form letter. GP reader Erik Houk received the same word-for-word response, as did our own GP correspondent, Andrew Eisen. But that's okay. Politicians get lots of mail and they almost always reply generically. Their staffs, however, take careful note of the concerns - and especially the volume of those concersn - expressed by constituents.

GP reader Jerad Hurst wrote to Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS), who chaired the Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing on video games on March 29th. Brownback wrote back, saying:

"Thank you for your recent correspondence regarding the regulation of violent content in the media... The availability of information through mass media and the Internet has opened a new set of problems facing parents who find it increasingly difficult to monitor the messages their children receive. Music, movies, and video games have grown increasingly violent. Moreover, there is some evidence to suggest that violent entertainment is actively marketed to young people by the entertainment industry."

"I am asking the parents... to listen to and watch the games, music, and movies to which their children are exposed. But I will also continue to call on entertainment industry executives to help parents, not undermine them, by providing parents with more content information and ending the scandalous practice of target marketing violent, adult-rated entertainment to kids. There are better ways to make money than by glamorizing violence and hate. I am not calling for censorship, but responsibility."




(29 comments) - (Post a new comment)

WOOOTTT!!
[info]yukimurasanada
2006-04-07 12:45 pm UTC (link)
First Dr. Walsh, now state Senators. AWESOME!!!!!!!

Hey Dennis, how bout for this sundays editoral, you put up all the different letters gp members have written that have gotten responses back?

Just a thought. Congrats to those members who are taking an active role in this fight. Lets do our best to support our industry.

(Reply to this)

Rock on
[info]bayushisan
2006-04-07 12:49 pm UTC (link)
Very cool! Much kudos to Jason and the others.

(Reply to this)

Warning: Off Topic
[info]blitzfitness
2006-04-07 12:51 pm UTC (link)
I'm at work now and was wondering if people can send me a link on something. I'm specifically looking for any research data that links videogames and stress, whether it be healthy stress, destressors, negative stress, etc.

I read something in a health and medical journal that I wanted to put a VG spin to and see how it looks.

(Reply to this)


[info]xenosphobatic
2006-04-07 12:51 pm UTC (link)
huzzah!

(Reply to this)


[info]silver_derstin
2006-04-07 01:34 pm UTC (link)
"As a grandmother, I often worry about what my own grandchildren are exposed to in video games"

Let me open my logical fallacy handbook and point it out... Ah yes. Appeal to Emotion. Trying to rouse our friendship by appealing to our sympathy of a poor grandmother.

Newsflash: I don't give a damn about your children or grandchildren. They are not a good reason enough to start censoring and controlling the media more then they already are.

It's great that we are getting responses, but those letters don't do ANYTHING. Maybe a full blown protest would do the trick.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]jindewinter
2006-04-07 02:15 pm UTC (link)
"Let me open my logical fallacy handbook and point it out... Ah yes. Appeal to Emotion. Trying to rouse our friendship by appealing to our sympathy of a poor grandmother."

This is her main logic on anything, always trying to make herself look like the good guy and play off of people's emotions and beliefs. She may of said
"Please know that I will keep your particular concerns in mind should the Senate consider this bill." but when I read that my BS alarm goes off.

As far as the protest, I doubt anything would come from it other than the news media having a feild day tweaking the stories around and making it seem like us evil gamers are protesting the idea of Keeping M rated games out of the hands of kids. Protests hardly ever work any more and when they do, it seems like they work in a negative aspect.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]thefremen
2006-04-07 05:38 pm UTC (link)
Diane is full of it. When the Mohave National Monument act (at one time SR-21) was under consideration we sent a few thousand letters (we being CORVA, CA4WDCA, and other like-minded non profit orgs) to her, and among them were letters from poor old grandparents who have finally been able to buy some land out in the desert for their retirement, and poor old farmers who wouldn't get a fair shake by receiving market value for their land when they'll have to buy land somewhere else at much higher rates.

What did she say to that? "Boo frickedly hoo, send me as much money as the Sierra Club and maybe I'll think about it." Well not really, but actions speak louder than words.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]silver_derstin
2006-04-07 07:06 pm UTC (link)
No? Really? An hypocritical politician? Where have I heard that before?

We should make a list of those politicians and publish it in a newspaper.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

So much for saving the Rain Forest...
[info]droinfinity
2006-04-07 09:11 pm UTC (link)
...Not enough paper in the world to make a list like that.
Maybe steal Santa's paper. You know, make a list. Who's nice, and who is a vote-scrambling hypocrite.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Whoa now....
[info]crackhuntress
2006-04-08 01:12 am UTC (link)
Anyone think that maybe she /is/ concerned for her grandchildren and the children of others and just happens to be unwittingly fond of overkill? Just because she isn't taking the /best/ course of action doesn't make her into an icon of all that is evil.

Other courses of action she may have taken in the past, of course, might just make her an evil figurehead. I'm not too sure, being fourteen and not really all that in touch with the world. I'm only referring to any game legislation she's launched. I admit my fallibility, however it's spelled.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: Whoa now....
[info]thefremen
2006-04-08 04:23 am UTC (link)
Hey, who says she's evil? I mean, she might just have been saying "I have grandkids and I worry" without meaning to manipulate in the same way you said "I'm only 14" and as a father that made me think like "awwwww, u lil' cutie pie!".

However, as a former resident of CA I did not enjoy most of the legislature she supported and authored, especially dealing with land use issues. I will say this for her though, she is a democrat who can win consistantly which is a very rare and special thing.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: Whoa now....
[info]crackhuntress
2006-04-08 03:22 pm UTC (link)
*shrug* That was simply the vibe that came off of several of the comments.

From what i've learned of the land issues, (Read: After reading the Boo Frickedly hoo thing...) I can mostly agree to what's being said, even though i'd love to learn more before i make up mind about something like this. I just wanted to make sure people were aware of the other perspective...

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Evidence
[info]keddren
2006-04-07 01:45 pm UTC (link)
"...Moreover, there is some evidence to suggest that violent entertainment is actively marketed to young people by the entertainment industry."

Yeah? Where?

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: Evidence
[info]silver_derstin
2006-04-07 02:08 pm UTC (link)
In her mind, just being a video game means that it must be marketed towards young people (which must mean 0-30, according to her age).

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: Evidence
[info]jaykaos
2006-04-07 02:56 pm UTC (link)
Precisely. That's 90% of their argument and the main problem with this whole damn issue.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Re: Evidence
[info]brerwolf
2006-04-07 06:41 pm UTC (link)
She's probably referring to a FTC investigation and several follow-up reviews conducted on the marketing of "inappropriate" content to minors by all three of the major entertainment retail industries (games, movies, music). The reports are all up at http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/congress/index.html , and are worth reading since they actually provide a few useful pieces of PRO ESRB material. For example, from the original report:

"The electronic game industry’s self-regulatory system is the most comprehensive of the three industry systems studied by the Commission."

and from the 21-month follow-up:

"Although some areas still could be improved, there is much in the game industry’s rating disclosure requirements that merits duplication by others."

At the same time, they seem to have some semi-valid complaints about "active marketing". The basic argument in the study is that many of the venues in which ads for M-Rated games, R-rated movies, and so on appear have large #s of teenagers in the audience. Some examples from the study would be TV spots during King of the Hill andThe Simpsons, and print ads in EGM and 100% Independent PSM. Of course, -WE- know that the "gaming enthusiast press" doesn't really have many publications that are solely read by adults and that you could only avoid having teenagers seeing the ads by not advertising M-rated games at ALL, but I suspect the FTC (and Sen. Feinstein) would say "That's your problem" ;P

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]jindewinter
2006-04-07 02:19 pm UTC (link)
"In my lifetime, I have watched an increase in gratuitous violence and indecent sexually-explicit material in video games and the media as well as on television and the radio"

Ok I am not doubting the TV and Radio claim, but Video Games? Does she actually play video games or does she base her judgements off of screenshots from the game and the crap "information" anit-gamers feed her like most of these politicians do?

(Reply to this)


[info]azron
2006-04-07 02:22 pm UTC (link)
notice how "jack thompson: ace attorney" fails to post excited replies to articles like this... how very strange

(Reply to this) (Thread)

He must be afraid...
[info]duncan_922
2006-04-07 02:46 pm UTC (link)
I can just picture him on a corner in his home, crouched on the floor whimpering: "OMG, OMG, OMG, if they organize, if the politicians start to notice that they are recognizing them as a political force.... It'll burst my little bubble!" "I'm ok, I'm ok"

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]attackgypsy
2006-04-07 04:30 pm UTC (link)
Give him some time, its only 12:30 EDT. He's probably not even out of bed yet.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]angry_man
2006-04-07 02:25 pm UTC (link)
I wish it was Tuesday, so that I could get a Hooah Two Times Tuesday from Domino's to celebrate.

I could really go for a thin crust pizza right now.

(Reply to this)


[info]xlorep_darkhelm
2006-04-07 03:51 pm UTC (link)
Heh... the only thing I got back from my senator was her basically telling me that she understands my concerns, but doesn't really give a damn about what I think. She feels that it would be negligent of her to not support any anti-video game law that comes up. But apparently its not negligent of her to just get a video game for her grandchildren from a store without being bothered to look up the rating and make sure it is OK for them.

Then again, this is the senator who single-handedly removed the military presense from the San Fransisco Bay Area, the same senator who when I was being harrassed unendingly in the Army and I wrote, her only response was along the lines of "Well, you were stupid enough to join the Army." as well as being noted as one of the most corrupt and twisted senators known for California...

(Reply to this)


[info]jabrwock
2006-04-07 04:54 pm UTC (link)
The availability of information through mass media and the Internet has opened a new set of problems facing parents who find it increasingly difficult to monitor the messages their children receive. Music, movies, and video games have grown increasingly violent.

The solution? Why regulate video games and leave everything else untouched of course! It makes so much sense!

Step 1: Denounce violence in all media
Step 2: Support bill that only targets a small portion of that media
Step 3: ?
Step 4: Profit!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]thefremen
2006-04-07 05:47 pm UTC (link)
The problem with media is movies/books like "V for Vendetta", "1984", "Farenheight 451", "Julius Ceasar", "The Prince" and "Plato's Republic". They all influence their poor little impressionable minds and convince them that they have to sabotage democracy no matter the cost.

I say we need legislation to prevent legislators from accessing any media that would give them funny ideas. (Oh yeah, that includes star wars too...) Tom Delay is a good example. He's resigning but says that he did nothing wrong and it was all on his subordinates. Sounds quite a lot like his childhood idol Richard "I am not a crook" Nixon.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]howdoyouplead
2006-04-07 10:06 pm UTC (link)
I think #3 is "Get funding from Best Buy."

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]the1jeffy
2006-04-07 05:59 pm UTC (link)
My leter to Arlen Specter. He hasn't even gotten back via a form letter. Nothing, not even an aide. I'm getting kinda pissed.

(Reply to this)

Jason = me
[info]marbledog
2006-04-08 01:43 am UTC (link)
Thank you for your kind comments, Dennis. I wrote a similar letter to all of the LA state reps, but I only recieved one reply (a form letter written by one of Burrell's aides).

(Reply to this)

Political Tipical
[info]zippydsmlee
2006-04-08 12:20 pm UTC (link)
Talk yet say nothing,these fools are realy annoying me ><
Their pay should be halved mabye then they will start working for us again >>

(Reply to this)

Cool!
[info]viridiscervus
2006-04-15 10:17 pm UTC (link)
I actually GET that paper!

(Reply to this)


(29 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…